| Ask A Lawyer We don’t make any promises, but we have a lot of bright sparks around here and if they have some spare time they just might give you essential advice. | 
06-29-2008
| | Junior Member | | Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 1
Rep Power: 0 | | 3 year old daughter sexually molested by father February 2002 my 3 year old daughter told me that her daddy pee-peed on her face and in her mouth. She stated that she licked his weenie and she got choked on it. I notified the local law enforcement in my town. Dept. of Children's Services were notify | 
06-29-2008
| | Junior Member | | Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 4
Rep Power: 0 | | Re: 3 year old daughter sexually molested by father There are already groups all over the country who have these issues on their plates - but these specific things aren't likely to change. Polygraphs in and of themselves are useless without other cooborating evidence - whether in this type of case, or any other. There are WAY too many problems with them to ever think that they will be useful in court - there are hundreds of valid arguements based on research that make them only slightly more technically reliable than a ouji board. CVSA tests fare somewhat better, but aren't widely used yet and even they don't often get accepted into evidence. These tests are used more for things like pre-employment screening, where the stakes are much less than in a criminal case, and where the goal isn't so much to get an accurate reading, as it is to hopefully intimidate the test taker to give truthful answers (oversimplified, maybe).
Reliability of any witness, child or otherwise, involves a lot of issues, and must be evaluated on a case by case basis. Even professionals in the field can't agree on how to determine levels of influence, coaching, memory, perception, reliability, etc. - and until they can do so, they have no chance of convincing law makers to rely on something that even the "experts" can't agree on.
You can get some good info about the inherent problems by checking out the research of authors like Gail Goodman, Bette Bottoms, Maria Zaragoza, John Graham, Gordon Hall, and Stephen Ceci. Check Amazon or your favorite bookseller - you can probably find used copies of their publications pretty cheap (as they are academic and professional authors, their stuff tends to be a little technical and rather pricy, so definately go with a used copy!). Get familiar with the issues, problems, and challenges inherent in children's testimony and THEN decide how to move forward with a letter writing campaign. Auto Accident Attorney Denver | | Domain Names Sponsor | | |
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | | | | Thread Tools | Search this Thread | | | | | Display Modes | Linear Mode |
Posting Rules
| You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts HTML code is Off | | | | | | |
If you are a Lawyer, Attorney, CPA, Accountant, Judge, Court Officer, Security Guard, Private Detective, Forensic Specialist, FBI Agent, Police Detective, Crime Scene Investigator, Police Officer, Sheriff, Bounty Hunter, Auditor, IRS Agent, County of State Official, or any other knowledgable legal, law, or other professional serving the public good, please register and help answer the many questions from our visitors and members. This public forum does not substitute legal consult, and is only for those looking to reach others who enjoy discussion on these topics. For entertainment purposes only! * PLEASE READ NOTICE BELOW | | | | An Important Note About CourtForum.com and CourtForums.com | | *NOTICE*: Please take notice that this is a public forum within which to discuss legal issues and concepts with other members of the public. This forum is designed for entertainment purposes only, and the communications had hereon are not necessarily factual or accurate and, if opinion, are not necessarily the opinion of the owners and operators of the forum. This forum is not designed to provide legal advice. Should a party claim to be an attorney or otherwise provide legal advice, and should you take action or incorporate such legal advice on your own behalf or the behalf of a third party, you acknowledge that you do so at your own risk. If you do not agree or accept the above disclosures please immediately exit the service.
| |